Montana and New York compared on the three taxes that decide a household budget: state income tax, sales tax and property tax. Figures use the official 2026 rates.
Tax year 2026 · Figures last verified November 2026
On $75,000 a single filer pays less income tax in New York — $177.00 less a year. Sales and property tax can still change the total, so the full comparison is below.
| Measure | Montana | New York |
|---|---|---|
| Top income tax rate | 7.40% | 10.30% |
| Income tax structure | 11 brackets | 8 brackets |
| State sales tax | 0.00% | 4.00% |
| Sales tax with local add-ons | up to 0.00% | up to 8.88% |
| Average property tax rate | 0.80% | 1.30% |
| Property tax on a median home | $2,054.00 | $4,270.00 |
| Income tax on $75,000 (single) | $3,697.00 | $3,520.00 |
Both states tax wage income, but Montana tops out at 7.40% and New York at 10.30%. The top rate only applies to the last bracket, so the effective rate on a normal salary is much lower in both.
Property tax is the line people forget: the average effective rate is 0.80% in Montana and 1.30% in New York. On a median-priced home that is $2,054.00 a year versus $4,270.00.
Montana
New York
Thinking about the move? Add income, sales and property tax together for your household.
The top marginal income tax rate is 7.40% in Montana and 10.30% in New York. Only income above each bracket threshold is taxed at the top rate.
The statewide sales tax rate is 0.00% in Montana and 4.00% in New York. Local district taxes apply on top and vary by city and county.
Income tax is only one part of the bill. Compare all three taxes — income, sales and property — for your own household with our move-savings calculator before deciding.
We use cookies for anonymous product analytics (Google Tag Manager and Vercel Analytics). Nothing loads until you choose. Cookie policy